Letter to Editor: Why We Need to Restore Fiscal Responsibility

Congressman David Cicilline talks below about fiscal responsibility on the national level.

The following is a letter to the editor sent to Patch from Congressman David Cicilline. 

Some political observers have suggested that Congressman Paul Ryan (R-WI) and the House Republican caucus demonstrated courage with their most recent budget proposal. I disagree.

There is no doubt that we need to restore fiscal responsibility in Washington, D.C. – on this point, nearly all of my Republican and Democratic colleagues agree.  We enacted cuts and savings that amount to $900 billion over ten years and agreed to at least $1.2 trillion more over nine years beginning in 2013.  Where we disagree is on whether cuts in federal spending need to come at the expense of important investments in our economic growth.

The House Republican budget proposal would devastate funding for the programs necessary to get our state through the current economic storm that has left us with the second highest unemployment rate in the country. In addition, it will increase the debt held by the public for ten years and not balance the budget for almost 30 years. It provides massive tax cuts to the wealthiest Americans and pays for these tax cuts by decimating critical investments in our future. 

With Rhode Island’s share of the economic recovery still struggling to take hold, the Republican budget proposes substantial cuts in education and workforce training, including $166 billion in cuts from student loans and Pell Grants over ten years – drawing from a playbook that has failed over and over again.  This isn’t courageous, and it’s wrong at a time when so many require retraining to develop the skills necessary to find work.  Our young people need education and training beyond high school in order to compete in the global economy of the 21st century.

In addition, the House Republican budget calls for deep cuts in highway funding, reducing transportation spending by at least 25% over ten years - slashing much-needed infrastructure investments that would put thousands of Rhode Islanders back to work.

Building a “path to prosperity,” as my colleagues on the other side of the aisle have claimed they are trying to do, means more than just repaving the nicest roads that our wealthiest citizens use – it means building new roads so that more Americans can achieve success if they work hard and play by the rules.

Rhode Islanders need a budget plan that will bolster job creation, strengthen our economic recovery, and support the middle class – not one that undermines the middle class, threatens our vital safety net, and instead provides greater tax cuts for the wealthiest Americans and corporations that are shipping American jobs overseas. 

During debate on the House floor, I voted in favor of the Democratic budget alternative authored by Congressman Chris Van Hollen (D-MD).  This proposal doesn’t punish success as some have claimed, but merely asks millionaires and billionaires to pay their fair share in helping reduce the deficit, and maintains significant investments that will help create good jobs for the men and women who have struggled to find work in recent years. 

The Democratic alternative would maintain vital, job-creating investments in our highways, bridges, and transit systems, along with investing in an initiative to help rebuild and modernize our public schools and improve the quality of education, helping to put more Rhode Islanders back to work immediately.

It would strengthen Medicare as it exists today so that future generations of seniors continue to have access to guaranteed health coverage.  And it achieves all this while getting our deficit under control.  The Democratic alternative would cut our deficit from 8.7% of GDP in 2011 to less than 3% of GDP by 2015 – keeping it at that level through at least 2023. 

Our federal budget isn’t just a list of ways to raise and spend revenue – it reflects our values as a nation.  And the differences between the budget proposals put forth by House Republicans and Democrats demonstrate the clear differences in how we define political courage.

House Republican Leaders believe our ship of state can’t make it through this current storm without throwing a few of our senior citizens, young people, and working families overboard so Big Oil, the special interests, and corporations that ship jobs overseas can make it through unscathed. 

I believe that true courage rests in asking everyone to pay their fair share, keeping the promises we have made to our seniors, and strengthening a middle class that is built to succeed in the 21st century economy. I am proud to continue fighting for these values.

Congressman David Cicilline

Manifold Witness May 21, 2012 at 11:17 AM
Frankly, Mr. Cicilline, this is about RI. Come on down to our level for a little plain talk. We don’t need your spin-speech on the lofty national scene. We cannot afford any more Cicilline fiscal irresponsibility. Or lies. Here in RI, government must make substantial cuts to expenses now. The expenses are growing at a rate that is unsustainable. The infrastructure is an unsafe mess. Here in RI, taxes are breaking the backs of all Rhode Islanders. We need jobs now. We could use some real, meaningful funding assistance for successful local businesses now, please. Another Cicilline term in office would devastate our state’s ability to get through the current economic storm that you and your lies helped leave behind for the rest of us. We have the second highest unemployment rate in the country – and it’s RISING. There’s no sugar-coating that with fancy-schmancy Washington political-speak. RI has seen NO share of ANY economic recovery. Cicilline lacks honor. Cicilline has done nothing for RI investments –those of us who still have a few bucks to invest cannot purchase RI municipal bonds - too risky. Cicilline’s not “built a path to prosperity” for his constituents. He has attempted to achieve success for himself by ignoring the sacred rules and traditional values that his constituents hold dear. Rhode Islanders need a Congressman we can trust. Not one who undermines us. Mr. Cicilline, please, just go home quietly.
Ted Geisel May 21, 2012 at 12:18 PM
Dear Mr. Cicilline, I have no doubt that in your mind you feel you are doing the right thing but America simply cannot afford this anymore. Myself and the majority of Rhode Islanders live within our means and it's time the government started doing the same. We owe more per person that Portugal, Italy, Spain and even Greece! How can you not see the writing on the wall? Don't you think it's a tad hypocritical to say the proposed budget won't be balanced for 30 years when you VOTED AGAINST a balanced budget amendment for the Constitution? Fiscal responsibility is obviously something you are against. Your voting record reflects that. "Our federal budget isn’t just a list of ways to raise and spend revenue – it reflects our values as a nation." I'm sorry but this is a lie. Around 65 percent of the public support a balanced budget. You do not and neither does the budget you support. We are in this mess in part because government has gotten too big and your solution seems to be... just make it a little bit bigger and it will fix everything. How about you put the power back into the hands of the people that made this county great. Let us control our own destiny. Not the government. Just to recap here: You voted AGAINST the balance budget amendment. You voted AGAINST the Cut, Cap and Balance Act of 2011. You voted AGAINST a bill that would return spending to 2008 levels. Your voting record does not reflect fiscal responsibility, does it?
Paul May 21, 2012 at 12:46 PM
David needs to join his brother in jail for his deception and cover-up of Providence financial mess.
Gary Morse May 21, 2012 at 04:20 PM
What the politician said: "I believe that true courage rests in asking everyone to pay their fair share". What the taxpayers heard: Government: good, taxpayers: bad
LauraP. May 22, 2012 at 06:52 AM
Ciccilline... The Name itself speaks to corruption, deception, dishonor and disgrace. How dare this individual think himself worthy of anyone's vote. That anyone would consider voting for such a scoundrel is ludicrous... but this, after all, is RI... the little state that COULDN'T. Our state is destroyed beyond repair. Get out now if you can.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »